SullivanU. That is a striking request and one that unelected judges should pause before granting. We have no power to decide this case. BLAG notes that virtually every culture, including many not influenced by the Abrahamic religions, has limited marriage to people of the opposite sex.
Archived from the original PDF on The Court decided not to answer the fourth question as it served "no legal purpose". Marriage; same-sex; reference; constitutional interpretation; constitutional law; proposed legislation; distribution of legislative powers; solemnization of marriage; discretion; Charter same sex marriage reference supreme court of canada in Detroit Rights and Freedoms ; section 2 a ; freedom of religion; section 2 b ; freedom of expression; section 15; equality rights; section 1; demonstrable justification.
More than 3, same-sex couples had already married in those areas before the Civil Marriage Act was passed. Hincks sought a divorce plus division of property and spousal support, Mr. Peter R. The Court went out of its way to state that they are not redefining "religious" marriage.
Same-sex marriage in Canada BC. January 14,
March 19, January 14, Retrieved February 12, As such, severing a key element of what has been accepted by all in favour of including something favoured by a few, calls into question whether "marriage" should continue to be a State function at all.
Archived from the original on September 13, In the end, the motion was narrowly rejected by a vote of
The Court began by considering the argument that the questions are not justiciable i. Congress has the power both to ensure efficiency in the administration of its programs and to choose what larger goals and policies to pursue.
Law Ann. Madison , 1 Cranch ,